Anti-profiteering in children’s homes and supported accommodation is gaining momentum and rapidly hardening into policy. Those boasting about making millions from housing vulnerable people are handing reformers their strongest ammunition. The government’s own independent review, chaired by Josh MacAlister, concluded in 2022 that care should not be based on profit. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 hands ministers a reserve power to cap profits in children’s homes and fostering agencies. The Health and Social Care (Wales) Act 2025 is phasing out private profit from children’s care in Wales. And in September, Andrea Egan, the general secretary of UNISON and a former residential support worker, called for profit to be removed from the sector altogether.

The examples driving the argument are the worst the sector has to offer, and the money at stake is large: the Financial Times reported in May that private providers charge the state an average of £384,020 a year for a child’s residential placement. In October, The Times published an undercover investigation into supported exempt accommodation, the housing-benefit funded end of the market that is separate from Ofsted-registered supported accommodation for 16- and 17-year-olds. It put the national supported housing bill at nearly £1.9 billion a year. One of its central figures is a Dubai-based landlord, Shaun Davis, who claims to have made £2.5 million in a single year from housing homeless people. The Times reports that he and his business partner, Luigi Newton, sell a mentorship course, the High Performance Academy, at up to £6,000 a year, teaching others how to do the same. It also reports Davis telling undercover reporters that a six-bedroom house in Wolverhampton earns £1,250 a month as an ordinary letting and £4,080 as supported housing, and advising targeting women fleeing domestic abuse because they are “grateful” and “won’t cause you any issues”. Both men deny wrongdoing: “We categorically reject any suggestion that we or the High Performance Academy have engaged in wrongdoing,” they told the paper. “Our business activities are conducted lawfully and we take our legal and regulatory obligations seriously.”

Most owners of children’s homes and supported accommodation are not that, and they know it. Their service has a payroll, a building, a manager registered with the regulator and a rota to keep whole. But policy aimed at the worst lands on everyone, and an argument this strong does not wait for nuance. What protects an honest owner is not a better press release. It is conduct: what the profit is used for, what the service gives back to its area, what it does for the wider cause of children, and what an outsider would see if they looked closely. That is worth spelling out.

What the money is for

A children’s home or a supported accommodation service is a real business. It carries a payroll, property, compliance, insurance and a rota that must never be short. A surplus is not optional: a service that cannot pay its way closes, and a closure moves a child, usually at short notice and usually far from home. A reserve is a safeguarding asset. So the question is never whether an owner should make a surplus. It is what the surplus is for.

The first claim on it is the staff team. Pay above the local market where possible, train continuously, and cover shifts with your own people rather than agency wherever you can. Continuity is not a soft metric in this work: the person who has known a young person for two years sees what an agency worker on a Saturday cannot. The vacancy problem is visible in Ofsted’s regulatory activity data for the year to March 2026: 12% of Ofsted-registered supported accommodation providers for 16- and 17-year-olds had no registered service manager in post. A home that keeps its people keeps what it knows.

The second destination is the building and the buffer. Maintenance spent before failure is cheaper than the crisis after it, and the repairs a young person never notices should be the ones an owner is proudest of. Then the reserve: months of operating costs set aside so that a crisis or a failed inspection does not become an eviction. What survives all three is the residue of care. What is taken after that is profit. The two look identical in the accounts and are opposites in practice.

The neighbour test

Every home is also a local economic actor, whether its owner thinks of it that way or not. It hires or imports. It buys from local firms or national ones. Its staff spend wages in the town, and its young people use the shops, clubs, GP surgeries and colleges around it. Two services with the same margin can leave opposite footprints: one woven into its area, one floating above it.

The practice is ordinary and visible. Hire locally where it is safe and sensible to do so. Use local suppliers for what the house consumes. Sponsor the team, support the food bank, make the home recognisable to its street rather than a mystery behind curtains. Commissioners already have a hook for this: the Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012 requires public bodies to consider social value when buying services, and placement contracts are where that consideration lands. An owner who can show the local footprint of their service is answering a question commissioners are learning to ask.

The contrast is the model the investigation exposed at its loudest: rooms filled through a benefit rule, wages and profits leaving the area, no visible contribution to the place whose taxes pay for it. That logic does not need to own your service to creep into it: agency cover bought at a premium, contracts won on price alone, a house that could be anywhere. The neighbour test catches it early. If the service vanished tomorrow, would the town notice?

The cause beyond your own gates

There is a wider duty, and it is not charity. The sector’s cause is the life chances of care-experienced children, and an owner is placed to advance it in ways that cost little. Sign the Care Leaver Covenant, the government-backed scheme through which organisations pledge jobs, apprenticeships and work experience to care leavers, and honour the pledge. Take work-experience placements for young people from other services, not only your own. Respond to consultations, join provider forums, share what works, and mentor new entrants, because a bad new entrant damages every good one.

This is also self-interest, properly understood. A business whose market is the public’s trust lives on the sector’s reputation, and that reputation is made by what its owners visibly do. The owner who furthers the cause is not donating to it. They are underwriting the conditions under which their own service is allowed to exist.

What to avoid

The avoid-column is conduct that reads as extraction. The loud version is in the news: millions claimed from housing the homeless, the Dubai lifestyle the Times investigation described, and the course it described teaching others to copy the model. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism and the Guardian reported councils spending hundreds of millions of pounds placing children in illegal, unregistered homes, where no routine inspection takes place. These are the examples that give the anti-profiteering argument its force, and every honest owner is judged against them whether they like it or not.

The quiet version matters more, because it is commoner. Drawings that grow while the training budget shrinks. Property bought through the company while shifts run on agency cover. A reserve consumed year after year by a margin taken by default. Luxury here is not a number in the accounts. It is a visible gap between what the owner takes and what the service has: the car against the rota, the holiday against the repairs list. Nobody in this sector should be ashamed of earning well from work they do well. The question is whether the earning depends on the service going without.

The test is simpler than any audit: if a young person who once lived in the home, their social worker and the commissioner who placed them could see the accounts and the year, would they recognise care in it? If yes, take the surplus and say so plainly. If the honest answer is no, the argument the reformers are making has already been conceded.

What this asks of an owner

Four habits hold most of it. Set the margin before the year and say what it funds, because a number decided in advance is a decision and a number discovered at year end is a habit. Ring-fence maintenance and training, the two costs that fail quietly. Pay yourself a salary for the job you do and treat profit as a separate decision, taken after the reserve and the backlog are funded. Keep one page of accounts the manager who runs the service can read: what came in, what it cost, what is left, what is held back. A manager who cannot see the money cannot make care decisions that carry financial consequences, and an owner who cannot explain the money is relying on nobody asking.

What changes next

Transparency is coming whether the sector likes it or not. The Act’s new financial oversight will make the composition of a margin visible, and group-level oversight, once commenced, will make a weak subsidiary a problem for its whole group. The owners who thrive under that regime are the ones already answering the question, because their conduct will read the same in public as it reads in private.

Children’s homes, and the supported accommodation that looks after children, exist on a simple promise: that a child who cannot live at home still gets a childhood worth having. Profit is not the enemy of that promise. Indifference to what the profit is for is. The best defence of profit in children’s care is not an argument. It is what it visibly pays for.